Case Management Leadership

The Patient as Leader: Recognizing the Expert Already in the Room

BY RAINE ARNDT-COUCH, DSW, JD, LCSW, CCM, FCM

Maria had learned the rhythm of healthcare conversations. Clinicians asked questions, case managers reviewed recommendations, and someone explained what needed to happen next. She answered, listened, and nodded.

After several emergency department visits related to poorly controlled diabetes, she expected another conversation about medication adherence, nutrition, lab work, and primary care follow-up.

All of those topics mattered. Yet none of them felt like the most urgent issue to her. That changed when one case manager began differently. After briefly reviewing why the referral had been made, the case manager said, “I can see what your doctors are concerned about. Before we decide where to start, what are you most concerned about?”

Maria paused, then responded, “I need to be able to finish my shifts at work. I’m so tired that I’m afraid I’m going to lose my job.”

The case manager didn’t redirect her back to the checklist. She didn’t explain why Maria’s primary concern should be diabetes management or admonish her for not saying what had previously been deemed the correct answer. Instead, she replied, “Then that needs to guide what we do next.”

Maria had probably been asked about her goals before, but this time her answer changed what happened next.

She wasn’t just being invited to react to a course of action professionals had already designed. She was being recognized as the person who knew best how any decision would fit into her life—and whose knowledge should influence the direction of care.

The Expertise We Too Easily Overlook

Healthcare professionals bring essential expertise. We understand diagnoses, treatments, risks, healthcare systems, and available resources. We may recognize clinical patterns that a patient can’t reasonably be expected to identify. But we aren’t the only experts in the room.

Patients know which symptoms are inconvenient and which make daily life impossible. They know what’s been tried, what failed, what caused harm, and what felt manageable. They understand work, caregiving, culture, transportation, finances, safety, and family expectations. Most importantly, they know what they’re capable of carrying right now. That knowledge may not appear in the medical record. An assessment tool may not capture it, and a diagnosis may not reflect it. Yet it’s essential to knowing whether a recommendation can become a sustainable action.

Person-centered care requires more than informing patients about decisions that have already been made. It calls for care that responds to the individual’s goals, values, and preferences and supports patients and professionals in developing the approach together (Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services [CMS], 2023). The CMSA Standards of Practice for Case Management similarly emphasize client-centered collaboration, self-determination, and shared and informed decision-making (Case Management Society of America [CMSA], 2022).

Patient participation and patient leadership are not the same. Participation gives the patient a place in the conversation. Leadership means the patient’s knowledge, priorities, and judgment have enough authority to change the direction of that conversation—and, when appropriate, the decisions that follow. Too often, however, patients are treated as experts only in their preferences: which option they like, whether they agree, or how satisfied they feel. Their expertise goes much deeper. They know what it will take to put a plan into practice. For example:

  • A clinician may know that a certain treatment offers the strongest evidence of benefit. The patient may know that its schedule will cost them their job, that its side effects previously made caregiving impossible, or that they can’t safely store the medication where they live.
  • A care team may believe a goal is achievable because resources exist. The patient may know that trauma, cognitive overload, family dynamics, or fear will make the next step harder than it appears.

This doesn’t make professional guidance less important. It makes the patient’s expertise necessary to use that guidance responsibly.

Asking Is Not the Same as Sharing Leadership

Healthcare professionals frequently ask patients what matters to them, but patients don’t always experience the question as an invitation to lead. Many have learned that there is a preferred answer. They may believe the care team wants to hear that they’ll take their medications, lose weight, keep appointments, or follow every recommendation. They may worry that naming a different priority will earn them the label of difficult, unmotivated, or noncompliant.

Some patients have shared what matters only to watch the conversation return to the professional agenda. Others have learned that disagreement leads to more education, persuasion, or warnings until they give the answer the team hoped to hear. Asking the question doesn’t necessarily share power.

Patients understand that their leadership matters when they can see a clear connection between what they say and what the care team does next. That connection is what turns participation into influence. Shared decision-making supports this same idea by bringing clinical evidence together with the patient’s values, priorities, and preferences rather than treating the patient as a passive recipient of professional recommendations (Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality [AHRQ], n.d.).

For Maria, the turning point wasn’t simply being asked about her priorities. It was hearing that her concern about employment would guide the work. Together, she and the case manager explored possible causes of her fatigue, prepared questions for her provider, identified appointment options that would reduce missed work, and selected one manageable self-care step.

The care team’s clinical concerns weren’t abandoned. Instead, professional priorities were reconsidered through the lens of an outcome Maria valued and a level of effort she believed she could sustain. Maria wasn’t asked only what she wanted. She was trusted to identify what she could realistically do, and that judgment carried enough authority to redirect the work.

Making Patient Leadership Visible

Patient leadership can remain abstract unless case managers show patients that their knowledge carries authority. Participation allows patients to contribute to a conversation; leadership means their knowledge and priorities have enough influence to change its direction. Several practices can make that leadership more tangible.

Name the patient’s expertise directly

Patients may not realize that their lived experience is just as necessary to good decision-making as the clinical information being presented. Case managers can name that expertise directly:

  • “You know your life, your limits, and your strengths better than any of us do.”
  • “I can explain the options, but I need you to tell me what each option would require from you.”
  • “I need your expertise to understand what’s”

This language tells the patient that the care team can’t create an effective approach without them. It also reflects the ethical principle of inherent dignity and worth of the person: each person can help direct their own care and brings knowledge that should influence the plan (National Association of Social Workers [NASW], 2021).

Ask about capability, not only willingness

When a patient doesn’t follow a recommendation, professionals may assume the person lacks motivation. A more useful question considers whether the recommendation exceeded the patient’s current capacity, such as:

  • “What would make this difficult to carry out?”
  • “How much of this feels manageable right now?”
  • “What would we need to change for this to become realistic?”

These questions recognize that capability is shaped by more than knowledge or desire. Pain, fatigue, depression, trauma, health literacy, financial pressure, and caregiving responsibilities all affect what a person can do.

Show the connection between input and action

After a patient identifies a concern, strength, or limitation, the case manager can explain exactly how that information changes the team’s response.

  • “Because keeping your job is your top concern, let’s first look at what is interfering with your ability to work.”
  • “You said transportation is the main barrier, so another appointment list won’t help until we address transportation.”
  • “You are telling me that three referrals at once would be overwhelming. Let’s decide which one offers the most immediate value.”

These responses demonstrate that the patient isn’t merely being heard. The patient’s knowledge is changing the team’s priorities, decisions, and response.

Let the patient define progress

Healthcare teams often measure success through clinical indicators, completed referrals, and adherence. Those measures matter, but patients can tell us whether care is improving daily life: more energy, fewer missed workdays, greater confidence, or the ability to manage one appointment without becoming overwhelmed.

The patient should help determine what improvement will look and feel like. This doesn’t mean abandoning clinical outcomes. It means connecting them to human outcomes. A laboratory result may show physiological change, but the patient can tell us whether that change has led to greater functioning, independence, security, or quality of life.

Offer real choices, and respect the answer

Choice is weakened when the only acceptable option is agreement with a predetermined recommendation. Understanding this, case managers can often create meaningful decision points even when clinical needs are pressing. A patient may be able to choose which concern to address first, whether education is provided verbally or in writing, who should participate in discussions, when follow-up should occur, or which self-management strategy feels most realistic.

Shared decision-making tools can improve patients’ knowledge, help them clarify what matters, and increase participation, although their effect on clinical outcomes varies (Stacey et al., 2024). Real choice also means accepting that an informed patient may choose differently than we would. Our responsibility is to ensure that decisions are informed and voluntary, not to make every decision match our professional preference.

Leadership With Support, Not Leadership Alone

Describing patients as leaders in their own care doesn’t mean assigning them sole responsibility for navigating complex systems or overcoming structural barriers. Patients may face transportation problems, financial strain, unstable housing, caregiving demands, language barriers, discrimination, limited health literacy, or fragmented systems. Motivation can’t repair a system that remains inaccessible.

Case managers still translate information, identify risks, coordinate services, address barriers, and advocate when systems fail. Patient leadership works best when professional expertise and lived experience operate together, with the patient directing what matters and the case manager helping make the path more understandable, accessible, and achievable (CMS, 2023; CMSA, 2022).

At the end of the day, the professional may know more about the disease, but the patient knows more about what it will take to live with it.

Why Engagement Matters

Research on patient activation—the knowledge, skills, and confidence people have to manage their health—supports meaningful participation. Higher activation is linked with better health outcomes, more positive care experiences, lower costs over time, and improved quality of life (Greene & Hibbard, 2012; Hibbard et al., 2015; Centers for Disease Control and Prevention [CDC], 2024).

We should interpret these findings carefully. Patient engagement doesn’t guarantee better clinical outcomes, and individuals shouldn’t be held responsible for circumstances beyond their control. Still, people are more likely to engage with care when they understand their options, see their own knowledge reflected, and believe their actions can make a difference.

The Aha! Moment

Maria didn’t need another reminder that diabetes mattered. She already knew that. What changed was realizing that what mattered to her carried authority in the conversation. When she saw her concern about work reshape the next steps, she became more willing to ask questions, describe barriers, and participate in decisions.

That’s the opportunity case managers have every day. We can treat patient input as information to collect, or we can treat it as leadership to follow. The difference shows up when we pause before correcting, ask what feels possible, change our direction because of what the patient has told us, and make clear that the patient’s goals, limits, and capabilities aren’t obstacles to good care. They are essential knowledge for deciding what good care should look like.

In the end, patient leadership isn’t a slogan or an extra step in the care process. It is what happens when our actions prove that the patient’s knowledge carries weight and their expertise can alter the course of care. Sometimes the most powerful moment isn’t when we give the right instruction; it is when the patient realizes, perhaps for the first time, “My voice changed what happened next.”

References

Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality. (n.d.). The SHARE approach. U.S. Department of Health and Human Services. https://www.ahrq.gov/sdm/share-approach/index.html

Case Management Society of America. (2022). Standards of practice for case management (5th ed.).

Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. (2024, June 21). Patient engagement. https://www.cdc.gov/health-literacy/php/research-summaries/patient-engagement.html

Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services. (2023, August 14). Person-centered care. https://www.cms.gov/priorities/innovation/key-concepts/person-centered-care

Greene, J., & Hibbard, J. H. (2012). Why does patient activation matter? An examination of the relationships between patient activation and health-related outcomes. Journal of General Internal Medicine, 27(5), 520–526. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11606-011-1931-2

Hibbard, J. H., Greene, J., Sacks, R. M., Overton, V., & Parrotta, C. D. (2015). Improving population health management strategies: Identifying patients who are more likely to be users of avoidable costly care and those more likely to develop a new chronic disease. Health Services Research, 50(2), 546–563. https://doi.org/10.1111/1475-6773.12224

National Association of Social Workers. (2021). Code of ethics of the National Association of Social Workers. https://www.socialworkers.org/About/Ethics/Code-of-Ethics/Code-of-Ethics-English

Stacey, D., Lewis, K. B., Smith, M., Carley, M., Volk, R., Douglas, E. E., Pacheco-Brousseau, L., Finderup, J., Gunderson, J., Barry, M. J., Bennett, C. L., Bravo, P., Steffensen, K., Gogovor, A., Graham, I. D., Kelly, S. E., Légaré, F., Sondergaard, H., Thomson, R., & Trevena, L. (2024). Decision aids for people facing health treatment or screening decisions. Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews, 2024(1), Article CD001431. https://doi.org/10.1002/14651858.CD001431.pub6

Dr. Raine Arndt-Couch, DSW, JD, LCSW, CCM, FCM, is a mission-driven, human-centered healthcare leader with experience in clinical social work, case management, behavioral health and population health. She is Chair of the CMSA Collaborative Relationships–Affiliate Committee, a CMSA Today Editorial Board Member, National Transitions of Care Coalition (NTOCC) Board Member, President-Elect of the CMSA Southern California Chapter, and former CMSA National Director. Her work bridges advocacy, whole-person care, and strategic systems transformation, balancing regulatory rigor with the human side of care delivery. She earned her MSW and JD from the University of Hawaiʻi at Mānoa and her DSW from the University of Southern California.

Image credit: YAVDAT/SHUTTERSTOCK.COM

Related Articles

Back to top button